Shopify vs. Etsy: Which Is Better for Your Business?

Shopify and Etsy both make it possible to sell products online, but they solve two very different problems.

Etsy is an online marketplace where your products can be discovered by shoppers who are already searching the platform. Shopify gives you your own ecommerce store, where you control your brand, website, customer experience, and marketing.

For many businesses, the decision comes down to a simple question: Do you primarily want access to an existing marketplace, or do you want to build an ecommerce business you control?

And for some sellers, the best answer is actually both.

Shopify vs. Etsy at a Glance

What Is Shopify?

Shopify is a commerce platform that lets you create and operate your own online store.

Instead of placing your products inside a marketplace alongside competing sellers, you create a branded storefront on your own domain. You control the design, navigation, product presentation, marketing, and overall customer experience.

Shopify also provides the infrastructure needed to run the business, including checkout, payments, inventory management, analytics, shipping tools, and integrations with other sales channels.

Advantages of Shopify

You control your brand.
Your store can use its own domain, design, navigation, photography, content, and merchandising rather than conforming to the structure of a marketplace.

You build your own customer relationships.
Because customers are buying through your store, you have substantially more control over how you communicate with and market to them.

It's built to grow with the business.
Shopify can work for a business making its first online sale as well as established merchants selling through multiple channels, countries, and physical locations.

You aren't limited to a marketplace.
Shopify can serve as the central commerce platform while you also sell through marketplaces and other channels.

There are no per-product listing fees.
Shopify plans allow unlimited products rather than charging you each time you create a product listing.

Disadvantages of Shopify

The biggest difference is that Shopify does not give a new store an instant audience simply because the store exists.

You are responsible for generating traffic through channels such as search engines, social media, advertising, email, existing customers, partnerships, and other marketing efforts.

Shopify also charges a recurring subscription fee whether you make a sale that month or not.

That makes Shopify a bigger commitment than simply placing a few products on a marketplace—but it also gives you considerably more control over what you're building.

How Much Does Shopify Cost?

Shopify's primary plans currently include:

• Basic: $29/month when billed annually

• Grow: $79/month when billed annually

• Advanced: $299/month when billed annually

Monthly billing is also available at higher monthly rates.

Payment-processing rates vary by plan and payment method. Shopify does not charge an additional third-party transaction fee when you use Shopify Payments.

Because Shopify changes its pricing and promotional offers periodically, check Shopify's current pricing before choosing a plan.

What Is Etsy?

Etsy is a marketplace focused primarily on handmade items, vintage goods, craft supplies, and other products that meet Etsy's seller requirements.

Rather than building a completely independent ecommerce website, sellers create a shop within Etsy's marketplace.

That's an important distinction because Etsy itself can be a customer-acquisition channel. Millions of shoppers visit the marketplace specifically looking for products to purchase.

Advantages of Etsy

Built-in shopper traffic.
For many sellers, this is Etsy's biggest advantage. Your products can potentially appear when shoppers search Etsy even if they've never heard of your business.

Low barrier to entry.
You don't need to build an entire ecommerce website before you start listing products.

Marketplace trust.
Customers already familiar with Etsy may be comfortable purchasing from an unfamiliar seller because they know the marketplace.

Particularly strong for certain product categories.
Handmade, personalized, artistic, vintage, and craft-related products can be especially well suited to Etsy's audience.

Disadvantages of Etsy

You have less control over your brand experience.
Your Etsy shop exists inside Etsy's website and must operate within its structure and rules.

You're competing inside the marketplace.
A shopper viewing your products can easily encounter similar products from other Etsy sellers.

Your business depends partly on Etsy.
Changes to marketplace policies, fees, or search visibility can affect your sales.

Fees increase with sales activity.
Unlike Shopify's primarily subscription-based model, several Etsy fees are tied directly to listings and transactions.

How Much Does Etsy Cost?

Etsy currently charges sellers a $0.20 listing fee per item. Listings generally expire after four months unless renewed or sold.

Etsy also charges a 6.5% transaction fee on the order amount, including applicable shipping and gift wrapping.

Payment-processing fees are separate and vary by country. Other charges can apply in certain circumstances, including advertising and currency-conversion fees.

Because those fees accumulate with each transaction, comparing Etsy and Shopify based only on Etsy's lack of a required monthly store subscription can be misleading.

Your actual cost depends heavily on how much you sell.

Shopify vs. Etsy: The Biggest Difference

The most important difference isn't the monthly price.

It's ownership and control of the customer experience.

With Etsy, you're participating in someone else's marketplace. Etsy brings together buyers and sellers and provides the environment in which the transaction happens.

With Shopify, you're building your own ecommerce destination.

That distinction affects almost everything else: branding, merchandising, marketing, customer relationships, competition, and how you grow the business over time.

Is Etsy Better for Beginners?

It can be.

If you're testing a handmade product and don't yet have an audience, Etsy offers a relatively simple way to start selling and potentially get your products in front of existing shoppers.

You don't necessarily need to build a complete ecommerce site before finding out whether people want your products.

But starting on Etsy doesn't mean you need to stay exclusively on Etsy as the business grows.

Is Shopify Better for Growing a Brand?

Generally, yes.

If your objective is to build a recognizable ecommerce brand, Shopify gives you much more control over the experience.

You can create your own website, use your own domain, customize the shopping experience, develop an email list, create content for search engines, and build marketing campaigns around your own store.

You also avoid putting your primary online presence directly alongside competing marketplace listings.

Can You Sell on Both Shopify and Etsy?

Yes—and for the right business, this can be better than choosing one or the other.

Think of Etsy as a sales and discovery channel and Shopify as your primary ecommerce platform.

An artisan, for example, might use Etsy to reach shoppers actively searching the marketplace while also building a Shopify store for the long-term brand.

That approach gives you the potential reach of Etsy without making your entire ecommerce business dependent on a single marketplace.

Should You Choose Shopify or Etsy?

Consider Etsy if:

• You sell products that fit Etsy's marketplace.

• You're just testing demand for your products.

• You don't currently have an audience.

• Marketplace discovery is more important than complete control over your brand.

• You want a relatively simple way to begin selling.

Consider Shopify if:

• You want your own branded ecommerce website.

• You want greater control over your customer experience.

• You plan to invest in SEO, advertising, email, social media, or other marketing.

• You're building a business you expect to grow.

• You want to sell across multiple channels.

• You don't want your primary ecommerce presence to depend on a marketplace.

Consider using both if Etsy is an effective acquisition channel for your products but you also want to build an independent ecommerce brand.

Ready to Start a Shopify Store?

If you've decided Shopify is the better fit, you don't necessarily have to start by paying for a Shopify plan while you're still building your store.

Ultrafade is a Shopify Partner with more than 10 years of Shopify experience. We can create your new Shopify store as a development store and transfer it to you when you're ready to launch.

That means you can take the time you need to prepare your products, content, design, and other store details before selecting a paid Shopify plan.

Whether you're starting a new ecommerce business or moving an existing store to Shopify, Ultrafade can help you determine the best way to get started.

Also in News